« All He Sees Are Her Sympathetic Eyes | Main | Old Heroes for a Strange New World »

When Good Men Do Nothing

Good (2008)


A radical concept lies at the heart of “Good,” the new film by Vicente Amorim adapted from the C. P. Taylor play. The notion is this: The Nazi party was not comprised entirely of evil men. Some of its members were in fact everyday citizens without any particular animosity towards Jews. At first such an idea proves startling, but upon deeper and more meaningful reflection it becomes apparent just how clearly valid it is.

In telling the story of a man swept up by the tide of National Socialism despite never subscribing to its tenets, the movie maintains a particularly terrifying feel. By refusing to caricature John Halder (Viggo Mortensen) even as he joins the propaganda apparatus, dons a uniform and neglects his Jewish best friend (Jason Isaacs), the film drives home its unsettling message: That could be us.

“Good” has been shot and played out with mannered artifice, from the wide shots of the scrupulously clean interiors to Mr. Mortensen’s rendition of his character’s compulsive passivity. This method greatly enhances the sense of banal superficiality that so often accompanies vile behavior and allows willfully ignorant accomplices to remain happily so. The filmmaker focuses things inwards, on small personal moments and the specifics of Halder’s particular journey. Only occasionally do the trappings of historical events come into play, and even then they remain small specters in the deliberate, studied portrait of Halder’s transition to party man.

Mr. Amorim and screenwriter John Wrathall have produced a compelling intellectual exercise, a movie that openly wrangles with complex ethical territory and never fears the controversial equation of a man wearing a swastika with something less than total villainy. Of all the recent movies to examine the period of history, this one does so from the most unique, universally affecting perspective. The distanced style makes emotional investment a challenge and things often seem completely hopeless. Yet, as Halder awakens to the horrible consequences of his inaction, a measure of redemption unfolds. As he takes desperate reparatory steps, the film shows us a man haunted by what he’s done and pleading with us to never repeat his mistakes.


Opens on Dec. 31 in New York and on April 17, 2009 in Britain.

Directed by Vicente Amorim; written by John Wrathall, based on the play by C. P. Taylor; director of photography, Andrew Dunn; edited by John Wilson; music by Simon Lacey; production designer, Andrew Laws; produced by Miriam Segal; released by ThinkFilm. Running time: 1 hour 31 minutes. This film is not rated.

WITH: Viggo Mortensen (John Halder), Jason Isaacs (Maurice), Jodie Whittaker (Anne), Steven Mackintosh (Freddie), Mark Strong (Bouhler) and Gemma Jones (Mother).


Post a comment

This weblog only allows comments from registered users. To comment, please Sign In.

© 2008-2023 Critic's Notebook and its respective authors. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use
Subscribe to Critic's Notebook | Follow Us on Twitter | Contact Us | Write for Us | Reprints and Permissions