Accidents Will Happen, Even When Love Is by Design

MOVIE REVIEW
Submarine (2011)

Submarine-craig-roberts-yasmin-paige-joe-dunthorne
Dean Rogers/The Weinstein Company

Oliver Tate — the 15-year-old protagonist played by Craig Roberts in Richard Ayoade’s feature-length directorial debut “Submarine” — expresses one of his desires to the audience early on in the film through voice-over narration: “I suppose it’s a bit of an affectation, but I often wish there was a film crew following my every move.” It’s a (sort of) clever gag since Mr. Ayoade is doing just that during the film’s 97-minute running time, and it’s also a standard representation of the type of comedy to follow: quirky, droll, almost mature, supposedly original. But while this kind of comedic bildungsroman has been repeatedly overdone, what saves “Submarine” from becoming the ugly sister to “Napoleon Dynamite” is its smart and strongly developed central character.

Continue reading “Accidents Will Happen, Even When Love Is by Design” »

Besides Adulthood, Nothing Is Confirmed

MOVIE REVIEW
Love Like Poison (2010)

Love-like-poison-un-poison-violent-clara-augarde-lio
Films Distribution

There is a disturbing recent trend in French cinema regarding teenage actresses, their bodies and the exploration of their sexuality as the plot of a film and the camera's exploration of their flesh as the milieu. This trend has, one hopes, achieved its apex in "Love Like Poison," a story so confused and degrading that the only sympathetic, normal character is a priest.

Continue reading “Besides Adulthood, Nothing Is Confirmed” »

The Crime-Fighting Irish

MOVIE REVIEW
The Guard (2011)

The-guard-brendan-gleeson-tribeca-film-festival
Sony Pictures Classics

“The Guard” is that rare breed of crime story that involves a passive protagonist, à la “Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil.” It’s not that the protagonist in “The Guard,” Brendan Gleeson’s Sgt. Boyle, apathetically takes a backseat as events unfold. He is simply more occupied with cracking wise, cavorting with prostitutes and tending to his dying mother than actually solving the case at hand. It is quite an achievement, then, that writer-director John Michael McDonagh manages to calculatingly frustrate and engage viewers simultaneously through the duration of the film.

Continue reading “The Crime-Fighting Irish” »

Out in the Sticks, a Bish-Bash-Bosh Journey

MOVIE REVIEW
The Trip (2011)

The-trip-steve-coogan-rob-brydon-bbc-tribeca-film-festival
Phil Fisk/IFC Films

One can never accuse Michael Winterbottom of making the same film twice, but “The Trip” comes pretty darn close. To be fair, the project is a six-episode BBC Two series edited down to feature length, but here you have Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon again as themselves à la “Tristram Shandy: A Cock and Bull Story.” The premise involves Mr. Coogan embarking on a cross-country journey to sample a few eclectic restaurants, and Mr. Brydon tagging along after Mr. Coogan’s American girlfriend drops out. Although fashioned after “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” what transpires instead is a British “Sideways” or “Old Joy” that substitutes celebrity impersonations for midlife crises — and not with stellar results.

Continue reading “Out in the Sticks, a Bish-Bash-Bosh Journey” »

In Feudal Japan, Rounding Up an Ocean’s 13

MOVIE REVIEW
13 Assassins (2010)

13-assassins-koji-yakusho-jûsan-nin-no-shikaku
Magnet Releasing

Takashi Miike has more than cemented his reputation as the sickest filmmaker known to man. Fans gush (and hurl) endlessly over each and every Miike defilement of all that is sacred, but rare is the mention of his fairly conventional and humble beginnings as Shohei Imamura’s assistant director. We actually got a sneak peek of his classical sensibility in “Audition” of all things, up to the point when the movie finally breached the boundaries of decency and earned cinematic infamy. His new film “13 Assassins,” though, is that true classical jidaigeki feudal epic that those who have seen “Audition” know he has in him. And Mr. Miike executes (pardon the pun) it so beautifully that it’s breathtaking.

Continue reading “In Feudal Japan, Rounding Up an Ocean’s 13” »

Kung Fu Hustler

MOVIE REVIEW
Detective Dee and the Mystery of the Phantom Flame (2010)

Detective-dee-and-the-mystery-of-the-phantom-flame-andy-lau-di-renjie
2011 Tribeca Film Festival

It’s a good thing that Tsui Hark has never jumped on the “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon” bandwagon. Although to be fair, he probably didn’t see any point in impressing audiences outside Hong Kong after his pair of underwhelming Hollywood one-two punch Jean-Claude Van Damme vehicles, “Knock Off” and “Double Team.” Poor Mr. Tsui. Even Mr. Van Damme has since redeemed himself with “JCVD” (which incidentally features a character who is an obnoxious hot-shot Hong Kong filmmaker, presumably based on you-know-who). Will Hollywood learn to forgive?

Continue reading “Kung Fu Hustler” »

Crucified on a Cross, Not Pitied

MOVIE REVIEW
Confessions (2010)

Confessions-kokuhaku-tetsuya-nakashima-kanae-minato-japan
Japan Society

“Confessions,” the official Japanese entry in the Best Foreign Language Film category for this year’s Oscars, made the shortlist of nine but fell short of a nomination. Curiously, the film has much in common with the eventual victor, Denmark’s “In a Better World.” Each tackles the subjects of revenge and vigilantism through the delinquency of a fair-haired juvenile mastermind and his social-misfit accomplice. But whereas “In a Better World” offers a cop-out ending with no actual harm done, “Confessions” serves up shattering collateral damage far and wide.

Continue reading “Crucified on a Cross, Not Pitied” »

When the Job’s Away

MOVIE REVIEW
My Piece of the Pie (2011)

Ma-part-du-gâteau-my-piece-of-the-pie-karin-viard-gilles-lellouche
Chantal Thomine-Desmazures/Studiocanal

With “My Piece of the Pie,” Cédric Klapisch seems to want to strike a happy medium between the hyperkinetic, post-E.U. “L’auberge espagnole” and the mature and hence snoozy “Paris.” The result recalls lighter Robert Guédiguian fare (think “Marius and Jeannette”), which entertains without offering anything of substance on its blue-collar protagonist disenfranchised by the global recession.

Continue reading “When the Job’s Away” »

Unearthing a Secret Carried to the Grave

MOVIE REVIEW
Incendies (2010)

Incendies-lubna-azabal
EOne Films

Nominated for an Oscar in the Best Foreign Language Film category, Denis Villeneuve’s “Incendies” uses Middle East unrest as a framework for classic Greek tragedy. What transpires is a brutal and compelling meditation on war, survival and reconciliation, even when its core Sophoclean aspect starts reaching really far into daytime soap territory.

Continue reading “Unearthing a Secret Carried to the Grave” »

The Blood of the Nocturnal Covenant

MOVIE REVIEW
Stake Land (2011)

Stake-land-connor-paolo-stakeland
IFC Midnight

Wrapped up somewhere within vampire apocalypse road movie "Stake Land" are two or three inspired touches. It's incredibly frustrating, then, that these are buried underneath an amalgam of earnestness and unoriginality. So derivative is Jim Mickle's third feature that at times it feels as if he and co-writer Nick Damici watched "The Road" and "28 Days Later" and simply decided to replace the cannibals and zombies with vampires.

Continue reading “The Blood of the Nocturnal Covenant” »

© 2008-2026 Critic's Notebook and its respective authors. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Subscribe to Critic's Notebook
Follow Us on Bluesky | Contact Us | Write for Us | Reprints and Permissions
Powered by WordPress